AMN Construction

How to compare two builders' bids: the same house, priced the same way

Two bids for the same drawings can differ by hundreds of thousands of dollars, and the lower one is not always cheaper. Before you compare totals, make the bids describe the same house. Here is how.

Hiring

The short answer: make both bids price the same drawing set, list their exclusions and questions, and line up allowances by category before you compare totals. The low bid with no questions about your drawings is usually the one that grows.

Send your plans to Matt

Make them price the same scope

  • Both bids should name the same drawing set, by date and revision.
  • Each should list what it excludes. A bid without exclusions has not finished reading the drawings.
  • Ask both builders for their list of questions about the drawings. If one has none, it priced its own guesses.

Line up the allowances

Allowances are where bids quietly differ. Put them side by side by category: tile, plumbing fixtures, lighting, appliances, cabinetry, landscape. A bid with low allowances looks cheaper and costs the same, or more, once you choose. Each allowance should say what it buys and when you must decide.

Then compare what is not a line item

  • Schedule: start, duration and the rainy-season plan.
  • Change terms: can work that changes the price start before you approve it in writing?
  • Fee on changes: what markup applies to added work?
  • Who runs the site, and how you hear about progress.
  • Warranty in writing, and how long.
  • License and insurance, checked on the state's site.

The low bid that costs most

The lowest number often belongs to the builder who read the drawings least. The gaps return as change orders, at prices you can no longer compare. A bid that comes with a written list of questions about your drawings is worth more than one that does not, even at a higher number.

Or give every bidder the same quantities

When we build the house as a 3D model from the full set, each trade prices the same measured quantities, step by step, with the number of visits it will make. Bids can then be compared line by line, because they describe the same house. How we build it first.

General information for owners, not legal advice. Check any California contractor's license at cslb.ca.gov.

Related: hiring a general contractor in Santa Barbara, fixed price, cost-plus or GMP and are your plans ready to bid?

Ask Matt about your project More writing

Built by Matt Newman. Licensed since 2002. Salt Lake City, Los Angeles, twenty years on this coast, and on every AMN site himself. One name on the contract. His story

Inquiries

Send us the bids. We will tell you where they differ.

Email them to purchasing@amnbuild.com. Matt reads them himself and writes back within two business days.

  1. Same dayMatt confirms he has it, and flags anything obvious that is missing.
  2. Within two business daysA written answer: what we see in your plans or your parcel, an order of cost, and the next step.
  3. Then nothing, unless you askNo follow-up sequence, no call from anyone else. The reading is yours to keep.

CSLB 802739 · Class B General Building · Licensed and insured · Two-year workmanship warranty, in writing

Updated November 2026